sixtyandme logo
We are community supported and may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Learn more

Do You Worry to Protect Yourself from Bad Things Happening?

By Nancy Lang Gibbs June 13, 2025 Mindset

Do you know that this is a real type of worry and that there is an actual name for it? Most importantly, do you know you’re not alone in feeling this way?

Back to that in a moment.

I’m going to share something with you that is very personal. Why? Because I believe that which is personal is often universal, and if my sharing a struggle will help you feel like you’re not the only one, then it’s worth it.

The truth is we’re all human and anyone attempting to pretend they have no fears and that they’ve got it all figured out, isn’t being truthful.

And let’s face it, being truthful means being vulnerable, and according to Dr. Brene Brown, a professor, lecturer, author, PhD, “Joy is the most vulnerable emotion we experience.” And one way of protecting ourselves from vulnerability, is what she calls, “foreboding joy.” She says, “We think that if we don’t worry, something bad will happen, or that if it does happen, we will be more prepared.”

Heaven forbid we feel too happy because that’s when the shoe will fall, right?! And if we worry just enough, that will keep the bad things from happening.

My Worry Story

Case in point, my annual exam is when my worry warts would come out in full force. I just knew that the one time I went into the appointment happy, filled with joy, not worrying about the outcome of the exam… that’s when I’d be caught off guard and something bad would happen. That’s when I’d get the scary news that something was wrong.

Intellectually, I knew that I was not that powerful and that worrying would not prevent bad news. I also knew that worrying would not keep me from being blindsided or scared if my worst fears came true. But the less logical part of me lingered and when I read more from Brene Brown I had a huge ‘A Ha’ moment. She said:

“The truth is, that you can’t practice tragedy and it doesn’t make us feel better. We’re not more prepared when something bad happens. What we do end up doing, however, is squandering the joy that we need when something bad happens. Joy is the most vulnerable emotion we experience, and if you cannot tolerate joy, what you do is you start dress rehearsing tragedy.”

I had been dress rehearsing tragedy and I wasn’t the only one!

What Does Dress Rehearsing Tragedy Look Like?

Dress rehearsing tragedy, she explains, is imagining something bad is going to happen when in reality, nothing is wrong. She said: “How many of you have ever stood over your child while they’re sleeping and thought, ‘Oh my God, I love you’ – and then pictured something horrific happening? Or woke up in the morning and thought, ‘Oh my gosh, job’s going great. Parents are good. This can’t last.”

We cannot go through life depriving ourselves from feeling joy to prevent our worst-case scenarios from happening!

So, What Do We Do About Our Worry?

In her research, Brene Brown met people who had a profound capacity for joy. “The difference,” she says, “is that when something really blissful happened to them, they felt grateful. Instead of using it as a warning to start practicing disaster, they used it as a reminder to practice gratitude.”  

Dr. Brown suggests when we feel the ‘what if’s’ come up, try to push those thoughts aside and focus on all the things you are grateful for. She also says to avoid honoring negative outcomes by ignoring your blessings.

In a nutshell: when we feel happy and full of joy and notice ourselves beginning to default into worry and dress rehearsing tragedy, the antidote is to lean into practicing gratitude.

What I’m Planning to Do

My annual appointment is a couple of months away, and yes, I’ve already felt that little black cloud trying to throw shade on my days and nights with the scary what-if’s. So, this is my game plan for myself and for those of you who have also become accomplished at dress rehearsing tragedy:

Acknowledge the Warnings

Instead of pushing those thoughts aside or ignoring them, which I think only helps them to grow larger and more threatening, I suggest acknowledging them and telling them thanks so much, they’re not needed anymore.

Replace Worry with Gratitude

Lean into and shine a bright light on everything that we are grateful for. Feel the glow from all the things that are good. As Martin Luther King Jr. said, “Darkness cannot drive out darkness, only light can do that.”

Let’s Reflect Together:

Do you dress rehearse tragedy? Do you think worrying will protect you from bad things happening? Are you one of the people who accept all the goodness in your life and naturally lean into gratitude instead of worrying?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
14 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Claudia

What a wonderful article! Thank you for the insights that I will use and share with friends.

Nancy Lang Gibbs

Thank you Claudia, that means more than you know!

Laura

Excellent article with helpful reminders. Thank you!

Nancy Lang Gibbs

Hi Laura! Thank youuu! Helped me remember too!

Rosanne

I practice a lot of gratitude, but other than that, this describes me well. I worry about any potential bad news, even if it’s quite unlikely. If it’s going to happen, I want to be able to see it coming. Yet with all my preparation, bad news still tends to blindside me! It wasn’t a mammogram or doctor’s visit that led to my breast cancer diagnosis – no, I was just mindlessly showering when I felt a lump. I have several stories like that. You can’t steel yourself or predict when something bad will happen. I still have to learn this, so thank you for the reminder.

Nancy Lang Gibbs

Rosanne that must have been so scary. Thank you for sharing this. We can do the best we can to be safe and healthy and then we need to live and enjoy and when something happens we deal with it. You did that and I hope all is well!!

Shelly

A good therapist I had many years ago once told me that worry is essentially superstition. You have an ingrained belief that if you worry, bad things won’t happen. It’s like throwing salt over one shoulder, or other acts believed to guard us and our loved ones. Let’s face it, our minds are tricky little buggars. The more we understand and can observe how the brain works and our own patterns of thinking, the more dominion we have over our runaway thoughts. And remember, your brain can get really stealth and subtle in how it gets you to stay worried, thus small. One of its most powerful tools for survival is to keep us clinging to familiarity.

Nancy Lang Gibbs

Yep!!! Thank you Shelly!

Liz P.

I think that there is a difference between planning for the worst (while of course hoping for the best) and “dress rehearsing tragedy.“ The former allows you to acknowledge the reality that things may go wrong, and make plans for if they do so that you are more prepared and relaxed/secure. The latter is unhealthy. I’m a big believer in planning for the worst while hoping for the best. It has saved my situation many times. Indeed it is what insurance is all about—-being prepared, because we know for sure that life throws things at us unexpectedly. To dwell strictly in optimism seems imprudent. And naive. But ymmv!

The Author

Nancy Lang Gibbs is the creator and host of the podcast Loving Later Life. She is also a published writer, Later Life Coach, speaker and actor. Nancy is passionate about women realizing that it is never too late to do what lights them up! You can email Nancy at nancy@lovinglaterlife.com.

You Might Also Like