sixtyandme logo
We are community supported and may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Learn more

Trusting Yourself Again: How to Stop Searching for the ‘Secret’ and Start Listening to Yourself

By Dawn Mariotti June 12, 2025 Mindset

I used to be the poster child for chasing the next big thing. A new diet? I was in. A shiny new personal development program? Sign me up.

A new way to organize your home? Done. Time management will solve all your problems? Here’s my money.

I was constantly starting something new, hoping the next thing would be the secret sauce. I was all in – again and again. But no matter how hard I worked or how many times I started over, I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was missing something. Like the real solution was always one book, one program, one system away.

And then it hit me: none of those programs were built for me. They were designed to be one-size-fits-all, but I wasn’t meant to be one-size-fits-anything.

I am custom.

The missing ingredient in every “breakthrough” was me actually trusting myself to know what was best for me to move forward – not some guru.

Why We Stop Trusting Ourselves

It’s easy to place our faith in a program or plan because, let’s be honest – if it doesn’t work out, we can blame the system instead of ourselves. And it’s easier to trust a program than ourselves when we’ve built a track record of breaking promises to ourselves or putting our needs last. That self-trust muscle gets weak.

We become the person we don’t trust.

We talk down to ourselves. We beat ourselves up for not being perfect. We hesitate to make decisions because we’ve convinced ourselves we always get it wrong.

And just like you wouldn’t trust someone who judged you or constantly let you down – it becomes hard to trust yourself if that’s how you’re treating you.

What Listening to Yourself Actually Looks Like

Rebuilding self-trust doesn’t happen overnight. It starts with learning to love and accept yourself as you are – warts and all. It means showing yourself appreciation, not just when things go right, but even when they don’t.

It means knowing that even if everything falls apart, you still have your own back.

Here’s what it looks like in real life:

  • Aligning your goals with your identity, not your insecurities.
  • Keeping the promises you make to yourself, no matter how small.
  • Using affirmations to gently rewire your inner dialogue.
  • Journaling not as a task, but as a conversation with yourself.

The Power of Small Wins

If you’re wondering where to begin, start by noticing where you’ve already shown up for yourself. Did you keep a promise today? Did you pause before saying yes to something that didn’t feel aligned?

Those small moments matter more than any “aha” from a book or seminar. Because self-trust is built in the trenches of everyday life.

What Self-Trust Feels Like

There’s a confidence that comes when you know you will deeply love and accept yourself no matter what. That kind of self-trust brings a quiet resilience. It doesn’t mean you always get it right – it means you don’t abandon yourself when you get it wrong.

So if you’ve been chasing the next secret or waiting for the perfect program to fix you, let me offer a gentle truth:

The answer isn’t out there.

It’s already in you.

You’ve always had the wisdom. It’s time to start listening.

Let’s Have a Conversation:

Have you lost trust in yourself? What has that lead to? Would you like to gain trust in yourself again?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
12 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Barb

I loved this article and I am a textbook case of looking for answers and I am starting to realize the best answers are inside of me and cost nothing other than my own time of paying attention to me. It is something I never learned that I am as capable as the next person and trusting myself is most important to my own happiness! Thank you for reminding me!

Dawn Mariotti

Ahhh yes — this gave me chills! You captured the exact shift so many of us are waking up to. It’s wild how much we invest in everything else before realizing the gold’s been inside us all along. I’m cheering you on as you keep tuning in and trusting yourself — that’s where the magic is. 💛 Thank you for sharing this!

CarolAnn

It’s a very appropriate topic for me right now – I’ve been giving myself a “talking to” regarding imposter syndrome and give myself credit. Very timely.

Dawn Mariotti

I hear you! Imposter syndrome is so sneaky — it shows up just when we’re stepping into something new or meaningful. Giving yourself credit is such a powerful move. You deserve to take up space and own your growth. I’m so glad the timing of this landed for you. You’re not alone! 💛

Mal

Whoa! Similar thoughts this week. If I had all the money I spent on “Self Help”…..

Thank you!

Dawn Mariotti

Right?! If I had a dollar for every “this is the one” program I bought… I’d probably have enough to start my own personal development empire 😂 But truly — the moment we start tuning into our voice instead of everyone else’s? Game changer. So glad this resonated! 💛

Jane

I love this article! It is so true and perfect. Thank you for the reminder and validation. 💞

Dawn Mariotti

Thank you so much 💞 That means the world to me. Sometimes we just need a little reminder that we’re not alone—and that we can trust ourselves again. I’m so glad it spoke to you! 💫

patricia

PERFECT and long overdue article. THANK YOU!!

Dawn Mariotti

Ahh, thank you! I felt the same—like this one had been waiting to be said out loud for way too long. So glad it landed for you. Here’s to finally trusting the voice that’s been there all along 💫💛

The Author

Dawn Mariotti is a mindset coach, speaker, and author of The Mindset Shift. She helps women in midlife rediscover their purpose and create lives they love through identity, mindset, and habits. Find her at dawnmariotti.com.

You Might Also Like